The hero of the game, Smith Rowe, is a computer-generated humanoid that players control. The goal for each level is to destroy all enemies and escape with your life by jumping over obstacles.
The “BBC” is a British broadcasting corporation. The goal of Smith Rowe was to make history by becoming the first ever team to win the FA Cup without conceding a single goal. They achieved this feat on May 19, 2018.
The referees deliberated for about three minutes before deciding whether Smith Rowe’s goal should be upheld.
The referees deliberated for about three minutes before deciding whether Smith Rowe’s goal should be upheld.Mikel Arteta stated he’d never seen anything like that before. Michael Carrick was relieved that he didn’t have to deal with it for long. Should Arsenal’s opening at Old Trafford, scored by Emile Smith Rowe, have stood or not?
Smith Rowe’s finish in Arsenal’s 3-2 loss at Manchester United on Thursday remained a significant talking point following a night of excitement, intrigue, controversy – and the milestone of Cristiano Ronaldo reaching 800 career goals.
It was shot in with David de Gea, United’s goalkeeper, hurt after teammate Fred stepped on his heel during a corner.
The goal was finally awarded by the video assistance referee, causing great confusion in the stadium and resulting in Arsenal delight and Manchester United rage.
Let’s get the facts straight before we hear what the managers, players, and experts have to say.
The events of the incident…
Martin Odegaard whipped in an Arsenal corner that Harry Maguire headed away, but only as far as Mohamed Elneny, who guided the ball to Smith Rowe 20 yards out, with 13 minutes on the clock.
De Gea was mistakenly trampled on by Fred at the time of the first clearing, leading him to fall to the ground on his goalline, where he remained with his back to play. When Smith Rowe’s ordinarily saveable shot was launched on aim, he was unable to react.
Seven seconds passed from the time the corner kick was taken to the time the shot was scored, during which time referee Martin Atkinson did not blow his whistle to stop play.
According to television footage, Atkinson did not see De Gea on the ground until Smith Rowe hit the ball, since the official was turning away from goal at the time to follow the play.
Shortly after the ball struck the net, Atkinson blew his whistle and wiggled his finger to indicate he had ruled the goal out.
It would take another three minutes and 15 seconds for a final verdict, with the goal being granted following VAR assistance.
Finally, because Fred was the one who got in the way of De Gea, there was nothing in the statutes that said the goal should be thrown out.
‘We could have stayed here all night,’ says the narrator.
When you allow three goals at Old Trafford, it’s always tough – Arteta
“I’ve never seen anything like it,” Arsenal manager Arteta later told Amazon Prime. “However, it was the referee’s judgment, and VAR confirmed that it was a goal.”
Michael Carrick, his United counterpart, announced his resignation from Old Trafford shortly after the game, which, along with the fact that United won, meant he didn’t spend much time addressing the event.
“At least I don’t have to speak about it too much now – we might have been here all night,” remarked the 40-year-old, who will be replaced in the dugout by Ralf Rangnick, the team’s new temporary manager.
“Normally, when the goalkeeper is down, we should halt the game,” said United player Bruno Fernandes. Players make errors.
“I’m not sure whether the referee made a mistake. That is possible if it is.”
The win against Arsenal was a ‘great night’ to end Carrick’s Manchester United tenure.
‘I’ve never seen something like it before.’
After Rob Green was playing for England’s B team against Belarus in 2006, he had a similar scenario as De Gea, with Belarus scoring when he was injured.
He also alluded to a similar incident involving Paulo di Canio in a game between West Ham and Everton in 2000 as part of his co-commentary duties at Old Trafford for Radio 5 Live on Thursday. The Hammers attacker could obviously see that the opposition goalkeeper, Paul Gerrard, was down before deciding to collect the ball and bring the game to a stop.
“I don’t believe Smith Rowe was aware,” Green remarked. “As he put it in, the player who scored past me for Belarus was laughing. Smith Rowe, on the other hand, was not.
“It’s the type of thing that happens now and again.” Di Canio caught the ball in a very sporting manner, but no one else had the chance to do so this time. Martin Atkinson was attempting to get out of the path as the ball was in the air and everyone was gazing at it.
“Everyone else in the crowd could see De Gea was on the ground, his back to the game, and his ankle had been stomped on by a teammate.” It is regrettable.
“As a former goalie, I’m thinking to myself, ‘bit of common sense, folks, you can’t save the ball if you’re down wounded with your back to the game.’
“I understand the clinical nature of refereeing and the argument that nothing prevents it from becoming a goal. But when you look at it in the cold light of day, you wonder, “What is the sporting decision?” It shouldn’t have been permitted, in my opinion.”
Former England captain Alan Shearer was on hand on Amazon Prime Video to provide a striker’s perspective if Green was speaking for the goalkeepers’ union.
“My first idea was goal,” he said. “I didn’t hear the referee blow and didn’t see the goalie being fouled.” That, I believe, occurs in every game. I don’t believe the goalkeeper should be sliding down like that, regardless of where the ball is.
“If there had been a major injury, there’s a case to be made that Arsenal should have let United score – but De Gea is walking about and not hobbling a minute later.”
Mark Clattenburg, a former Premier League referee, was there with Shearer to provide an official’s perspective.
“I’ve never seen anything exactly like this,” he said. “Martin Atkinson couldn’t do anything. His instinct was that there was a foul, but you can’t sound the whistle until the ball is in the goal.
“If he had blown the whistle first, there would have been more controversy.” I’m confident Jadon Sancho would have halted play if he had won the ball [and cleared].
“He didn’t see De Gea on the ground. Martin isn’t looking at the goalkeeper, and it isn’t until Smith Rowe strikes the ball that he notices him and wonders, “Why is De Gea down?” Then he’ll believe there’s been a foul.”
The dispute at Old Trafford also reminds me of a situation in 2019 at Elland Road, when Leeds kept playing and scored via Mateusz Klich against Aston Villa, who had a man down for the whole game.
Marcelo Bielsa, the Leeds manager at the time, elected to let Villa score an uncontested equalizer, a decision that won him a Fifa Fair Play award.
If you’re using the News app to access this page, please vote by clicking here.
Watch This Video-
Related Tag
- youtube
